Planet India
How the Fastest-Growing
Democracy
is transforming America
and the World
by Mira Kamdar Scribner. NewYork 336 Pages
Reviewed by Mahadev Desai
Following her acclaimed and award winning memoir, Motiba’s
Tattoos, Mira Kamdar has written a thoughtful, well-researched,
comprehensive and highly informative Planet India: How the
fastest-growing democracy is transforming America and the world.
No stranger to
India, Kamdar has traveled extensively, interviewed and met
with corporate leaders, celebrities, social activists and people
in different walks of life to paint a rich and endlessly
fascinating portrait of political, cultural and social forces
shaping India.
In the very first Chapter, she emphasizes that no democracy in
history has undergone a transformation of India’s magnitude and
velocity. India is world’s youngest but vibrant multicultural,
multireligious and multilingual democracy and also fourth
largest economy. India has the youngest population (50% of
India’s people are under 25) on the planet and a middle class as
big as the population of the entire United States. Not only is
India the ideal market for the next thing, but with a highly
skilled English-speaking workforce, elite educational
institutions like the famed Indian Institutes of Technology (IIT)
and Indian Institute of Management (IIM) and growing foreign
investment, India is emerging as an innovator of the technology
that is driving the next phase of the global economy. Over 70%
of global entertainment revenue is expected to come from Asia by
2015, and India alone will account for half of this. India
deserves a place in reconfigured United Nations Security Council
Organization.
But she also highlights the age old problems that India needs to
grapple with immediately because it does not have the luxury of
time. It has a tiny affluent minority, a rising materialistic
and acquisitive middle class, and 800 million people who live on
less than $2 per day.” Our biggest challenge is the challenge
nobody has solved in the world: how to grow equity”Mukesh Ambani,
Chairman of Reliance Industry, told Kamdar.India faces all the
critical problems of our time-extreme social inequality,
employment insecurity, caste divisions,a growing energy crisis,
severe water shortages, a degraded environment, global warming,
a galloping HIV/AIDS epidemic, terrorist attacks,-on a scale
that defies imagination.
India has become a major source of skilled, low cost labor, with
a corps of English-speaking, highly skilled workers who can
compete with the best, especially in technology and science, for
a fraction of what a comparable worker is paid in the U.S. or
Europe. No wonder jobs in finance, technology, life sciences,
human resources and business management are being outsourced to
India. “Any business that doesn’t require physical presence can
be outsourced”Azim Premji, CEO of WIPRO, one of India’s largest
Companies said. Alan Blinder, a Prof. of Economics at Princeton
University calls this the third industrial revolution. The first
was the shift of labor from farms to factories; the second was
the shift from manufacturing to services and the third is a
shift made possible by the information age. Big multinational
corporations are accessing India for research and development,
and also for markets. India’s 1.2 billion and 20 million strong
Diaspora are beginning to flex their cultural and economic
muscles. Evidence of India’s renaissance is everywhere-in Indian
fashion, music, movies, art and letters.
70% of India’s population lives in rural areas, where they are
dependent on agriculture.-mostly small scale farming. Over the
next ten years, hundreds of thousands of these people will flood
into the cities, putting even greater stress on the already
burdened infrastructure and creating a massive need for new
jobs. To help with jobs, India Government has passed Rural
Employment Guarantee Act. But agriculture needs to be
revitalized. Rural India has become home to perhaps the most
experimental and revolutionary methods of idea sharing and
trade. Agribusiness giant ITC has installed several communal
information kiosks called e-Choupals to bring local farmers
access to innovative farming techniques as well as new trading
partners from around the world. In Andhra Pradesh, e-service
centers help villagers to get electronic records of birth
certificates, marriage certificates, tax returns, land titles
etc.and also to pay bills.
India must be energy independent, by developing alternative
sources of energy like wind farming, biofuels etc. Recently
India and the U.S.have signed the Nuclear Energy Bill but it has
received a mixed reaction in both the countries. American
Corporations though expect to earn $20 to $40 billion from this
civil nuclear agreement. India also faces severe water crisis.
It has 17% of the world’s population but only 4% of world’s
fresh water.
India also needs to address Health and Education (Especially
Primary) crisis. Critics argue that while India tops the
developing world in buying conventional weapons, it spends only
1.3% of its budget on health care. 70 million Indians cannot
afford to see a doctor or buy medicine. India must use digital
technology for telemedicine, and remote diagnostics, and provide
inexpensive generic drugs to the population. The Gates
Foundation spends 300% more on AIDs awareness, prevention and
treatment than the Indian Government does. The Heroes Project,
co chaired by actor Richard Gere and Parmeshwar Godrej in
partnership with Kaiser Family Foundation and with a grant from
the Gates Foundation is leveraging celebrity power and the media
to increase awareness about HIV/AIDs crisis. India is facing an
education emergency. Last year, Pratham, an NGO in Primary
education, in it’s Annual Survey of Education Report stated that
of an estimated 140 million children in primary school in India,
30 million cannot read, 40 million cannot even recognize an
alphabet, and 55 million will not complete even four years of
school. One of the most innovative ways to extend educational
opportunity is via distance learning over wireless internet
connections. Some of the reasons for the abysmal state of
primary education are lack of schools with basic facilities,
child labor, and internal migration of parents, teacher
shortages, and teacher absenteeism. There are encouraging signs
of some inspired individuals, NGOs, and the private sector
taking on the challenge of improving the quality and reach of
basic education in India, however. And same goes for efforts
(chiefly by women activists to save the country’s environment
from the wanton destruction of unchecked exploitation.
Kamdar celebrates the ‘Can- do spirit among Indians.” Everywhere
I was stunned by the pride, the bullishness, the sense that this
moment belongs to India. I caught a glimpse of India’s future,
its possibilities and its perils, and in that future I saw our
own, for as goes India, so goes the world,’ reflects Kamdar.
Planet India, with Mira Kamdar’s in-depth research, abundant
up-to-date data and scholarly analysis is essential reading for
anyone interested in the future of America and the world.
Mira Kamdar is a Senior Fellow at the World Policy Institute
since 1992, and an Associate Fellow of the Asia Society. She has
provided expert commentary on India for CNN International News,
the BBC, and NPR. She lives in New York with her husband and two
children. |